Bakery FAQ's

Where are you located?

We are located on Library Road in Bethel Park, PA. Right near the large intersection of South Park Rd, Baptist Rd, Library Road (Rte. 88), and Corrigan Drive. There is a Papa John's Pizza Shop on the corner and our building is right behind theirs.  

Do you have parking available?

Yes! We have 9 parking spots available and our building is completely handicapped accessible.

What types of payment do you accept?

We accept Cash, all major credit cards including American Express, Personal Checks, and Give Mia Cookie Gift Cards. There is a $5.00 minimum for credit card purchases.

Do you have gift cards available?

Yes!  Gift cards can be purchased in any denomination starting at $10.00.

What are your prices?

Our in-stock cookie prices can be found here.  Specialty sugar cookies range in price depending on the size of the cookie, the intricacy of the design, the amount of icing colors, etc.  An average price for one dozen specialty sugar cookies can be anywhere from $21.95/dozen-$29.95/dozen.  For specific pricing on a particular design just give us a call at 412-831-1616 during regular business hours.

Do you offer coupons or discounts?

We occasionally offer fun promotions and discounts in our bakery. Has anyone ever caught the $5 FILL-A-BOX on Saturday nights?  Best ever!  Just follow our Facebook page for the most up-to-date information!

Do you ship cookies?

We are not currently offering shipping at this time.  We can offer you packaging instructions if you would like to ship the cookies on your own. 

Product FAQ's

What ingredients are used in your sugar cookies?

The ingredients are as follows: Unbleached All Purpose Flour, Butter, Vegetable Shortening, Sugar, Eggs, Pure Vanilla Extract, Pure Almond Extract, Baking Powder, Salt, Confectioner's Sugar, Pasteurized Egg White, Corn Syrup, Glycerin, FD&C Red#40 & #3, Yellow #6 & #5, and Blue #1 & #2. All cookies are made on equipment that may contain nut and peanut traces.

Are your cookies allergy friendly?  Do you offer Gluten-free or sugar-free items?

All of our cookies are made using shared equipment so there is no way for us to make nut-free or dairy-free cookies.  We do not currently offer gluten-free or sugar-free options.

Do your cookies really taste good?

Yes! The sugar cookie remains soft and chewy and the icing is the perfect sweet touch to compliment the cookie.  At our bakery you get great looking and great tasting cookies!

Do I have to pre-order my cookies or do you have cookies available for purchase all the time?

We have fresh assorted cookies and seasonal sugar cookies in stock at the shop each day which can be purchased by the piece or by the dozen.  If you would like any more than 2 dozen per flavor or 6 dozen total, then we do recommend calling at least one day ahead so that we can make sure to have your cookies ready.  We bake fresh small batches all throughout the day so calling ahead is much appreciated for our stock purposes! Click here to check out our in-stock options. 




How much notice do you require for special cookie orders?

The more notice you can give us, the better! We always recommend that as soon as you know the event date and the approximate quantity of cookies needed, contact us to reserve a spot on the cookie schedule, especially if it is a large event like a wedding or corporate party.  We take orders up to six months in advance and we tend to get fully booked 4-6 weeks in advance (This time frame may vary during peak seasons).  Don’t ever hesitate to call and ask about availability for a specific date, we can always check the schedule and let you know if we have a spot available!  By only taking so many orders per week it allows us to bake your order fresh and to allow enough time for the hand-decorating process that each cookie requires! We will never ever sacrifice our quality in order to take on more projects each week.

What is the minimum order quantity for a special cookie order?

The minimum order for specialty sugar cookies is one dozen.  You get the best price per cookie if that one dozen is all the same design, but you are welcome to break a dozen into multiple designs for an additional charge per design.

How do I place an order?

Give us a call at 412-831-1616 or stop into the bakery to place your order.  We mainly use email to communicate with customers who already have an order spot reserved, so if you do send an email about placing an order you will most likely receive an auto-response to give us a call during business hours.  Calling and speaking to one of us is the best way to get an immediate answer to your question/order inquiry.  We are busy in the kitchen all day so we don’t always get to emails right away!